That review makes for an interesting read.
It does indeed, Brian, but I find a number of deficiencies and inaccuracies in it - I hope Charlie does not mind my being TL;DR here. Many of you will now I am a stickler for accuracy, and I am not just waving the flag for one of our Valued Members.
Credit where credit is due.
1.
Refracta is one of the more cryptic and least friendly system installers I have used and it takes an unusually long time to get through compared to Ubiquity and Calamares. It's a curious choice for a young distribution.
Nowhere near as bad as Anaconda, used by Fedora and some others, whose dark theme makes options to manually partition next to impossible to see. I had no problems with Refracta.
2.
Earlier I mentioned there is sometimes overlap in functionality. We see this a little with the two web browsers,...
IMO, any user of Linux for some period of time is a little short-sighted if they do not have two browsers on board, for backup and comparison.
3.
LXQt is a light-to-middle weight desktop and so I was surprised to see it consumed a lot of memory, about 750MB. This puts LXQt running on Expirion on par with heavier desktops like Plasma 5.
That is nonsense. 750 MB is not a lot of RAM, at all.
In my stable of 70+ distros, I have eleven (11) with KDE Plasma.
My Expirion 6 is Xfce, not LXQt. I do have an LXQt, but it is Lubuntu.
For a legitimate comparison, below is a list of them and their consumption of RAM, "at rest"
Code:
/dev/sda9: LABEL="KubuntuNoble-HDD" 1.3 Gi (KDE Plasma v: 5.27.12)
/dev/sda17: LABEL="MJRO-KDE-HDD" 1.3 Gi
/dev/sda27: LABEL="BigLinux-KDE-HDD" 1.6 Gi
/dev/sda30: LABEL="BluestarKDE-HDD" 1.5 Gi
/dev/sda35: LABEL="Neptune8-KDE-HDD" 1.3 Gi (KDE Plasma v: 5.27.5)
/dev/sda41: LABEL="Mageia9-KDE-HDD" 809 Mi (KDE Plasma v: 5.27.10)
/dev/sdb6: LABEL="Tuxedo-KDE-SSD" 1.5 Gi
/dev/sdc19: LABEL="CachyOS-KDE-WD" 1.3 Gi
/dev/sdc32: LABEL="MX23.5-KDE-WD" 1.2 Gi (KDE Plasma v: 5.27.5)
/dev/sdc33: LABEL="Q4OS-KDE-WD" 1.3 Gi (KDE Plasma v: 5.27.5)
/dev/sdc38: LABEL="Feren-KDE-WD" 885 Mi (KDE Plasma v: 5.27.10)
Those unmarked on RAM usage use Plasma 6 up to KDE Plasma v: 6.3.2 or more
My Expirion 6 (Xfce)
/dev/sda22: LABEL="ExpirionXFCE-HDD"
1.0 Gi (Xfce v: 4.20.1)
My Lubuntu (LxQt) 1.0 Gi (LXQt v: 1.4.0)
/dev/sda15: LABEL="LubuntuNoble-HDD"
On Plasma versions - Plasma 6 was released February 2024, the Plasma 5 (5.27) series is only being supported now for serious bug fixes and translations.
My Xfce of Expirion, at 1.0 GB, and Jessie Smith's (DistroWatch) 750 MB under LXQt are by no means heavy.
If you are going to compare apples, compare them with apples, not oranges.
As far as I am concerned
@GatorsFan , well done, and more power to you.
Wizard
(chuckle) I
could provide this to DistroWatch as my review of the project - do you think it would last, or fall through the cracks?